Caffeine: The Good, The Bad, The Ugly

by lydia on January 25, 2013

Okay, maybe my title was a bit deceiving since I don’t plan on talking much about the apparent ‘good’. Caffeine cartoon/ecard Coffee smells and tastes great, yes! It’s like a form of art. One of life’s simple joys for many. Believe me, I was a major coffee afici0nado for many years and even worked at Starbucks! I had a reputation and it was a known fact if you came to my house you were gonna get a killer cup o Joe! So, what happened to that season of my life? I came to realize caffeine was my drug of choice (along with sugar), and I no longer wanted to be dependent on a substance to drive my energy. I also knew that I felt better overall not dependent on coffee, so I quit drinking it. That was the spring of 2009 I believe. For two years I felt awesome with no caffeine and was so glad to be free of the burden I used to feel NEEDING coffee. Then one day, I started drinking a cup of tea here and there. Life got stressful and I drank tea more often. Next thing you know I’d go in cycles of using that cup of tea to drive my energy. Since I had burned out adrenals a few years back and likely low cortisol (I’ll know more for sure soon after some testing) I have to be very careful to manage my diet/sleep/stress in order not to crash my adrenals again.  In the past year I’ve found that I’ve needed something to get me going in the morning quite often though not daily. Thankfully, I could stop drinking it any time without withdrawals, but recently over the holidays, I found myself letting more caffeine sneak in on a regular basis to the point that it was hard to give up. Not just caffeine from tea, but coffee (which is higher) and my gluten intolerant gut can’t deal with the possible cross reactions to gluten (more on that later). There is no guilt on my part for it, just simply a realization that something is off and I should rather work to resolve it more holistically than just give into the false energy from a cup of tea or Joe. I’m sure many of you can relate. It isn’t easy being a single mother of 4 boys, and sometimes I don’t keep up with taking care of myself as well as I know to. Thankfully, I am informed enough to know I just don’t tolerate coffee and it needs to be something I avoid. Weak tea is more tolerable for me and the occasional cup is fine.

While there may be some people who seem to ‘do well’ on coffee, I am learning that it’s really not ideal for anyone to consume on a regular basis. Of course it’s always a choice whether to consume it or not, however today I want to talk about why I think it should be kept as an occasional ‘treat’.  This post is about caffeine in general though, so I won’t isolate coffee unnecessarily. It just seems the top choice of Americans to get their caffeine fix, after all; ‘America runs on Dunkin‘.

Caffeine & Blood Sugar

The BIGGEST reason I knew I needed to quit coffee; it affected my blood sugar. Starting my day off with a cup or two of coffee really messed up my blood sugar. I didn’t understand that fully then, but I do now. That same year I quit coffee was the same year I finally got my blood sugar under control. Prior to that time, I was hypoglycemic, reactively so. That was NOT fun! Read more here on how your blood sugar works.

Since caffeine can increase blood sugar it can aggravate hypoglycemia and diabetes. When it is combined with sugars, it can be even more devastating to your blood sugar level. It can be a contributor to insulin resistance. Something not one of us alive should take very lightly. Caffeine is a stimulant that is used to ‘drive’ one’s energy. Stimulants aggravate blood sugar issues and deplete two important neurotransmitters, serotonin and norepinephrine.

Caffeine raises blood sugar levels and disrupts the blood sugar–regulating effect of insulin. In fact, high-dose caffeine administration (the equivalent of six cups of coffee) has been shown to produce transient insulin resistance that is very similar to Type II diabetes.

Hypoglycemia results when blood sugar levels fall below normal. Since blood sugar (or glucose) is the fuel that runs our muscles and brain, hypoglycemia typically produces fatigue, depression, and anxiety. There is no single cause of hypoglycemia. It is an imbalance in the complex process of energy metabolism involving the liver, pancreas and adrenal glands. Caffeine plays a major role because it stimulates the fight-or flight stress response. As part of this response, the liver rapidly raises the blood sugar levels. This is felt as a “lift” by the person who drank the coffee (especially if the coffee contained added sugar) but the body must then deal with the metabolic emergency of hyperglycemia (elevated blood sugar). This is accomplished by the pancreas, which secretes insulin, driving the blood-sugar level down. In some individuals, however, blood sugar may decrease to levels below normal, resulting in hypoglycemia and the all-too-familiar “letdown” feeling a few hours after the coffee lift. Of course, many people simply reach for another cup of coffee, which starts the roller-coaster cycle all over again. (Stephen Cherniske, M.S., ‘Caffeine Blues’.)

Caffeine & Hydration

Caffeine is a dehydrating beverage, and requires one to drink MORE water to replace what was lost thanks to a cup of Joe. For every 8 ounce cup you will need to replenish with another 12 to 16 ounces of pure water. Caffeine’s diuretic effect causes loss of potassium, calcium, magnesium, zinc and other minerals, the B vitamins, especially thiamine, B1 and vitamin C. Since dehydration is the most common deficiency in our culture, I am certain that caffeine and other dehydrating beverage consumption is a key contributor.

Caffeine’s Effect on the Adrenals

Those with low cortisol may seem to benefit from coffee. The problem is the consuming coffee is only exacerbating the underlying problem. I think it can be okay to consume small amounts while working to resolve issues with low cortisol, though I think it would be best if adaptogenic herbs were used. Why? Caffeine can trigger a boost in dopamine which activates the pleasure center in the brain. The same thing that cocaine, amphetamines and other psychoactive drugs do. Again, it’s an energy driver, so it’s not going to resolve the root problem. Those with high cortisol that drink coffee, ooh mama, watch out! When your cortisol levels are already high and you add the stimulation of coffee/caffeine you are asking for trouble. Caffeine over stimulates the adrenal glands by creating a stress response in the body as we saw above in the role that caffeine plays in affecting our blood sugar. It creates an upswing in cortisol and other stress hormones. Whenever we have a rapid rise in our blood sugar, there is always a quick drop to follow. Both the high and the low can have an effect on the adrenal glands. In the book ‘Caffeine Blues’ there is a chapter describing just how caffeine consumption can contribute to leading the adrenals in dysfunction and habitual use can take you through all 3 stages of adrenal fatigue to the point your adrenals totally crash. Then you are in trouble, because let me tell you it’s very difficult to recover from deep adrenal fatigue. Adrenal fatigue and caffeine just do not mix. The reality is, the more you over stimulate your adrenals with caffeine, which ultimately leads these already overworked glands, the sooner you end up in complete adrenal exhaustion. If you believe you could be suffering from adrenal fatigue you should get an ASI test (adrenal stress index) done to see what your cortisol is doing. Read more about how one’s blood sugar affects adrenal health and even the entire endocrine system.

Coffee & Gluten Intolerance

Unfortunately, simply avoiding gluten for those with celiac or gluten intolerance is not enough if you want full recovery. There are many foods that are cross reactive to gluten and coffee is one of them. Cyrex Labs has a gluten-associated cross-reactive foods and foods sensitivity test that you can order and find out for sure if indeed coffee is something you need to avoid. Personally, that test is kind of expensive for me, so I just need to avoid it for now. This post by Paleo mom may shed some more light on why coffee consumption is not a good idea for those sensitive or allergic to gluten.

French Press Coffee

Caffeine/Coffee Substitutes

This list is namely for coffee or tea drinkers. I don’t drink soda or energy shot drinks, but I will address those in another post.

  •  Organic Decaf Coffee (Swiss Water Process) – I can suggest using this as a way to help you wean off of fully caffeinated coffee. However, if you are gluten intolerant you might not be able to drink it if you want to heal. (*Note: I test fine for a couple types of decaf coffee -but have tried to drink Starbucks and simply cannot as I do not believe it is gluten free. It’s important to know how to muscle test or pulse test so you can determine if a given food is causing your body a reaction.)
  • Dandy Blend – I have not personally tried Dandy Blend, but know MANY who have and love it. The taste is very satisfying from what I understand. The bonus to this beverage is that it is a good liver support as well as an enjoyable beverage and coffee replacement.

  • Green Tea- On occasion this would be a good replacement until you can wean off of the need to stimulate your energy. Since green tea holds more health benefits and has a much lower dosage of caffeine per cup, it could be a great option for most. However, for someone in deep adrenal fatigue, I recommend getting off the caffeine until you’ve healed for some time.
  • Adaptogenic Herbal Teas-  such as siberian gingseng, schizandra, astragalus, ashwaganda and others. I like Ashwaghanda and have used it often, I like to blend it with an orange blossom tea since it isn’t the yummiest of teas (though it’s not bad either).
  • Kombucha -this is a fermented tea beverage with very little caffeine left in it (though it does have some). The benefits of kombucha help to support the body instead of subtract nutrients. It is loaded with b vitamins, enzymes and some probiotics. It’s a very energizing beverage you can easily make at home. I consider it more of a tonic. Highly recommended!
  • Bullet Proof Coffee – If you are simply not willing to give up that one cup of coffee a day because it’s your one vice that you look forward to, at least make it bullet proof. What is bullet proof coffee you ask? It’s coffee with a good amount of fat added to slow the effect on your blood sugar and adrenals. For each cup of coffee add 2 Tbsp. of grass fed butter and 1 Tbsp of coconut oil, blend for a minute in the blender. It makes a nice froth! Add a touch of raw honey or green stevia and serve. I still don’t recommend this for those in adrenal fatigue or those with gluten intolerance, but it’s a lot better when you add enough fat.

Affiliate links are used where appropriate, which allow me to earn a small commission on your sale. This does not affect your price at all and is a cost of doing business for the affiliate companies. The monies earned from those commissions are like a tip at a restaurant and help support the maintenance of the website and free content. Shop on Amazon?  There’s a handy Amazon.com search box over in the right-hand side bar you can click through to shop on Amazon. You’ll get the very same prices, plus a portion of what you spend will support this site. Thank you!

 

LydiaLydia Joy Shatney is a certified Nutritional Therapist Practitioner through the Nutritional Therapy Association. Additionally, she is the chapter leader for the Weston A. Price Foundation in Delaware County, Pa. (Find the group here on Facebook). Lydia is also a member of the Nourished Living Network. Lydia founded Divine Health in March of 2010. You can find Lydia on Facebook, Twitter & Pinterest.

Lydia offers specialized step by step counseling to transform your health. Personalized consultations to suit your specific needs are offered via phone, Skype or in person. Lydia offers a variety of packages offered to suit your individual needs. Contact Lydia today to get started as well as to learn more about what she has to offer you!

If you enjoyed this post, please share!

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

Heather January 26, 2013 at 8:07 am

Hi Lydia!

I didn’t have time to read the entire article – I’ve never drank coffee, but wondered what you thought (or if you’ve ever thought!) about coffee enemas. I’ve read that they are helpful in getting the detox and digestion paths going. Any thoughts?

Reply

lydia January 26, 2013 at 8:31 am

Heather,

I am aware that people swear by coffee enemas, but I have many hesitations. I think there are other ways to detox and support digestion. The ultimate goal should always be to iron out digestion through the north to the south, remove food allergies and get the thyroid checked. Detox can be supported by diet, exercise, herbs that cleanse the liver and sweating every day, detox baths and more. It is my belief that the coffee enema could disrupt the appropriate pH of the colon. If one does choose to use a coffee enema they will still get the caffeine effect and will need to make sure it is organic etc and replace the gut flora afterwards by doing a probiotic suppository or implant. Hope that helps! I don’t have any scientific literature to show me coffee enemas are safe or not if one were to use them regularly.

Reply

Tina January 26, 2013 at 9:07 am

Thank you for this article. I gave up coffee last May after being a serious coffee drinker myself for 17 yrs. Got through the 3 days of detox hell and swore off the stuff forever. I have to say my blood sugar has never been so level, and I have great energy now. My ibs has improved greatly as a result as well. Best decision I ever made. Praise God.

Reply

lydia January 27, 2013 at 12:42 pm

That’s awesome Tina!

Reply

Jamie January 28, 2013 at 11:33 am

I hate coffee but what are your thoughts on Organic teas with caffeine, like Numi Organic Cardamon Pu-erh (ancient healing tea packed w/ anitoxidants) that has caffeine? I don’t drink it often but every now and again.

Reply

lydia February 3, 2013 at 9:09 am

Jamie,

I don’t think it’s a problem to enjoy something like that from time to time. It’s the dependency on caffeine to drive one’s energy that is a problem and can mask deeper health issues. I myself plan to enjoy teas like that though not daily or because I NEED them for energy – low caffeine teas can offer some good health benefits. If someone is not in adrenal fatigue or has blood sugar issues consuming some caffeine here and there should be okay.

Reply

Tracy January 28, 2013 at 6:24 pm

You keep switching back and forth between talking about caffeine and talking about coffee. There are other forms of caffeine that are very good for us – raw cacao, dark chocolate, green tea, yerba mate…

It gets confusing because, yes, coffee isn’t good for us (especially those of us with chronic health conditions), but other forms of caffeine ARE good and healthy.

Interesting article, though. Thank you. :)

Reply

lydia January 28, 2013 at 6:31 pm

I don’t agree that caffeine is good for us really. There are some forms with far less caffeine, such as green tea that may have other benefits consumed occassionally. However, if someone has a lot of health issues, caffeine in any form is not really the best idea. Yes, coffee is a big one, soda is too (which I will address in another post). Dark chocolate has some benefits and some down sides too. The point of this post was to bring out caffeine in general, but I did focus a lot on coffee since it seems to be the caffeine of choice, and pretty high in caffeine quantity as well. I believe I explained that a bit. Anyway, I’ll dig into more soon in other posts – so stay tuned.

Reply

Rebecca February 20, 2013 at 9:12 am

Dark chocolate… well, I have been off sugar for almost 6 months now, and have found ways to make use of healthy products to get sweets… I started by using unsweetened baking cocoa powder, coconut oil, raw honey/stevia, etc… but then purchased raw organic cacao powder and wham! the theobromine (stimulant) afffects me way worse than caffeine ever did. I think the raw organic kind is more potent because it is unadulterated and not processed… so I have to avoid it now. But everyone else in my family loves it.

I drink maybe one or two cups of Jasmine green tea per day. I wish I could find de-caff but I haven’t been able to find a reasonably priced decaf Jasmine green tea. Oh well. That is the only time I get caffeine other than the minute amounts in homemade chocolate.

And I have switched the hubster over to de-caff coffee.

Reply

Debbie February 20, 2013 at 11:14 am

Thanks for sharing that caffeine affects blood sugar. I didn’t know that .

Reply

Mafalda March 12, 2013 at 10:53 am

Hello Lydia! I’ve just stumbled upon your blog and loved it!

It’s quite useful. I don’t drink coffee because I am sensitive to caffeine. Still, I really enjoy drinking tea, especially black tea in the morning. It gives me the energy push I need. However, recently even black tea or oolong tea have given me headaches, so I am turning to herbal teas more often.

I’ve been drinking Austragalus tea. It’s a good option I have to confess. The flavour is different of course, but it is very useful to fight exhaustion, fatigue and boost the immune system, so I am quite happy with my newest discovery.

http://www.therighttea.com/astragalus-tea.html

Reply

Daniel March 31, 2013 at 12:05 pm

Many people believe that most of the caffeine in tea is contained in the first infusion, so steeping tea for 30 seconds or so, then dumping out the resulting liquid and drinking the next two or three infusions would greatly reduce the amount of caffeine in tea. Not everyone subscribes to this theory though, but it is common in China.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: